​

​

​

I have tried to make a strong, evidence-based case for students to reconsider their decision to leave Pakistan and immigrate to the UK, primarily due to the financial burdens and unrealistic expectations involved.

 

Here’s a step-by-step framework you could follow to build a comprehensive cost-benefit analysis, alongside a SWOT analysis to compare both economies. I’ll guide you through the steps, which you can later refine as per your expertise.

​

​

1. Objective of the Analysis

​

To convince students that emigrating to the UK may not be as beneficial as it seems, with a focus on financial costs, socio-economic challenges, and the potential advantages of investing in Pakistan’s local economy.

​

2. SWOT Analysis for Pakistani Students Moving to the UK

Strengths (Perceived by Students):

​

• Better Educational Opportunities: Availability of globally ranked universities.

• Perceived Higher Standard of Living: Some believe life in the UK is more comfortable or prestigious.

• Global Exposure: Living in a multicultural society with potential global job market access.

Weaknesses:

• Massive Financial Outlay: Flight, visa, tuition fees, lawyer fees, accommodation, etc. UK university fees can range from £10,000 to £30,000 annually for international students.

• Debt Burden: Many students take out loans to cover costs, leading to years of repayment.

• Uncertain Employment: High competition for jobs, particularly for non-UK citizens. Rising unemployment rates are a significant concern.

• Legal Challenges: Visa restrictions, costs of immigration lawyers, and the risks of falling into illegal status if they can’t secure a post-study work visa.

• Cost of Living: With the high cost of rent, food, and transportation in cities like London and Manchester, savings are quickly depleted.

Opportunities:

• Educational Qualification: A UK degree might open doors to international opportunities.

• Potential Work Experience: Some students might secure jobs, but even then, employment rates for non-EU citizens are not guaranteed.

• Entrepreneurship or Networking: Some students may find opportunities to start a business or build valuable networks in niche sectors.

Threats:

• Brexit Impacts: Post-Brexit immigration rules have become stricter, and the job market for international workers has tightened.

• Unemployment and Economic Instability: The UK is also experiencing unemployment challenges, making job hunting post-graduation difficult.

• Crime and Social Issues: The rising rates of crime and hate crimes towards immigrants could be a significant threat to personal safety and well-being.

​

3. Comparative Analysis: Pakistan vs. UK

​

Pakistan Economy Overview:

• GDP Growth Rate: Projected around 3-4% in recent years with potential to grow further in sectors like IT, manufacturing, and agriculture.

• Cost of Living: Significantly lower than in the UK.

• Entrepreneurial Opportunities: With the right investments, students could start businesses in Pakistan for a fraction of the cost of their education in the UK.

• Government Schemes: Supportive schemes for entrepreneurship, such as the Kamyab Jawan Program and ease of doing business reforms.

• Employment: While unemployment exists, sectors like IT, digital services, and start-ups are growing, providing more opportunities domestically.

 

UK Economy Overview:

​

• GDP Growth Rate: The UK is a developed economy, but recent growth has stagnated post-Brexit and due to COVID-19 impacts.

• Cost of Living: Exponentially higher than in Pakistan, especially in urban areas.

• Unemployment: The UK’s unemployment rate is around 4-5%, but international students face tougher competition due to visa restrictions and fewer job openings.

• Job Market for Foreign Nationals: Post-Brexit, it’s more challenging for non-EU nationals to secure jobs due to stricter visa requirements.

• High Debt & Financial Pressure: Students can rack up massive debt due to the cost of education, with limited job security post-graduation.

 

4. Cost-Benefit Analysis

 

Costs of Moving to the UK:

1. Education Costs:

   • Average tuition fees for international students: £10,000 - £30,000 per year.

   • Living costs: £12,000 - £15,000 annually.

   • Total for a three-year degree: Approx. £66,000 to £135,000.

2. Visa and Legal Fees:

   • Visa application: £348 for a student visa, additional for work visas.

   • Legal fees for visa assistance: £500 to £2,000.

3. Travel Costs:

   • Round-trip flights: £600 to £1,200 per trip.

4. Opportunity Costs:

   • Foregoing local business opportunities in Pakistan.

   • Post-study work visa challenges.

Benefits (Realistic Assessment):

1. Job Prospects:

   • On average, many international graduates face delays finding jobs or receive lower salaries due to visa restrictions and high competition.

   • Many end up in low-wage jobs just to extend visas or stay legally.

2. Long-Term Debt:

   • The potential debt burden can take years to repay, with some students falling into precarious financial situations.

3. Emotional & Cultural Cost:

   • Students may struggle with homesickness, discrimination, or feeling alienated in a foreign country.

Alternative - Investing in Pakistan:

1. Entrepreneurship:

   • The same £30,000 to £50,000 used for UK education can help establish a local business in Pakistan.

   • Opportunities in agriculture, tech startups, and digital services are expanding.

   • Government incentives and fewer bureaucratic hurdles for young entrepreneurs.

2. Cost of Living:

   • Living costs are lower, meaning savings or business investments have more purchasing power.

3. Potential for Higher Returns:

   • With Pakistan's emerging markets, a business can thrive with fewer costs than the burden of education abroad.

​

5. Conclusion

​

In conclusion, the financial burden, uncertain job market, and socio-cultural challenges facing Pakistani students immigrating to the UK outweigh the perceived benefits. Many students will end up in significant debt, potentially working in low-wage jobs just to survive.

​

On the other hand, staying in Pakistan offers promising opportunities for entrepreneurial ventures, where the same investment used for education abroad can be applied towards creating businesses. By providing advisory services, I as a Business Finance Advisor, can help you realise that they can contribute to their homeland's economy and live a stable, prosperous life without the hurdles of international debt and uncertain futures.

My Role as an Advisor: I can step in by offering consultancy services on how to leverage government programs, secure financing for startups, and provide strategic guidance for young professionals and entrepreneurs. This would give students an alternative to fleeing their homeland, helping them build a future within Pakistan’s growing economy.

​

6. Sham Marriages & Illegal Migration Risks

​

Additionally, many students resort to illegal immigration methods or sham marriages to stay in the UK. These actions carry legal and social risks, which can lead to severe consequences like deportation, imprisonment, or being blacklisted from future visas. It's vital to emphasize that these paths rarely result in long-term success and often create a cycle of exploitation and legal entanglement.

Would you like assistance with any specific financial calculations or additional data on GDP, costs, or more details to strengthen this analysis?

​

​

​